Cookie Snobs Unite

Did you know that I am a cookie snob?
Yep, it's true.
I never eat store bought cookies (unless they are Girl Scout Cookies, of course!)

And, I have rules for homemade cookies.
They must be soft.
Hard cookies are no good....I am all about under baking my cookies to make sure they are soft enough.
Cookies are better if they are thick & chewy.
Small, thin cookies are no good (in my humble opinion)

A few years ago, I finally found a Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe that met all my standards.
They are not your typical chocolate chip cookie, but they sure are yummy!

The BEST Chocolate Chip Cookies!

Here is what you need:
2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 cup butter, softened
3/4 cups packed brown sugar
1/4 cup white sugar
1 package instant vanilla pudding mix (3.4 ounce size)
2 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 bag chocolate chips ( I always use milk chocolate)
*optional: 1 cup chopped nuts (I never add nuts, but if you like nuts, add them!)

Yes, you read that right, you add a box of instant vanilla pudding!
And, I ALWAYS use milk chocolate chips (no semi sweet for this family.. to each their own!)
I told you I was a cookie snob!
I always have the girls help me when we make cookies.
They love to help.
Mostly, they make a mess, but that is okay, it keeps them entertained!
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Sift together the flour and baking soda, set aside.
In a large bowl, cream together the butter, brown sugar, and white sugar.
Beat in the instant pudding mix until blended. Stir in the eggs and vanilla.
Blend in the flour mixture. Finally, stir in the chocolate chips.

Drop cookies by rounded spoonfuls onto cookie sheets.I use a cookie scoop...So much easier & less mess!
Bake for 10 to 12 minutes in the preheated oven.
Edges should be golden brown. Don't over cook them!
(I always check them at 8-9 minutes)
And, I store the cookies in an air tight container with a slice of bread in it!
The bread dries out, but keeps the cookies soft..try it!
Kevin taught me this trick!
I always use the heel of the bread because that is the only thing it is good for...does anyone actually eat the heel of the loaf? Yuck!
Are you a cookie snob also?
What tips & tricks do you have when making cookies?

P.S. 4 more days left to enter the
Pioneer Woman Cookbook & Book Giveaway!


  1. Okay YUM! I am totally with you on the soft and chewy vs thin and hard! MUCH prefer them that way!

    I LOVE using a cookie scoop. I got one a few months ago and have never looked back!

    The vanilla pudding sounds SO creative - I definitely might need to try that!

    But I'm a semi-sweet girl. The darker the better! :)

  2. I make this recipe too. They are always a hit. I am a cookie snob as well. No small hard cookies for this mamma!

  3. The ONLY store bought cookies I'll eat are those cake cookies with the frosting and sprinkles. I don't know if that qualifies me as a cookie "snob" though. Vanilla pudding, huh? Interesting!

  4. I'm ashamed to say that I use the pre-sliced cookies in the nestle package (hangs bag over my head)

  5. yep my daughter only eats Oreos & my homemade cookies! I like big thick soft cookies. No pancake cookies for me. =) thx for sharing recipe! I will try w/my girls soon!

  6. ok. This is scary. True story, all of it. The never buy store cookie, yuck. Loathe the dry crunch cookie, ick. Couple years ago (in the Gooseberry Patch Pinch of this Dash of that) I found that recipe. Until then really didn't make Chocolate Chip Cookies all that much....they turned out flat. No soft gooey center, all issues.
    THIS RECIPE IS THE BEST. Can't miss! Works every time, brings tons of compliments & I love em. I've even changed the pudding flavors for fun. Like Chocolate pudding & white chocolate chips or peanutbutter ones.
    Blogs are so cool
    ~Ada in Coastal Cali
    ps Is your PB family trip coming up soon?

  7. 2 thoughts with this post:

    1. pudding? really?

    2. bread? really?

    I will be trying both :)

    Thanks for the share

  8. I can make a gourmet meal, muffins, pies, cupcakes. But cookies... NOT SO MUCH! I have been trying for years to master the simplest chocolate chip cookie recipe and they still come out flat. :( Fingers crossed your recipe does the trick. Thanks for sharing!

  9. Vanilla pudding makes everything better, right? My daughter has no school today and guess what we may be doing.....;-) I'm right there with you on the soft and chewy thing. Wonder if it has to do with my Mom always leaving out or even substituting an ingredient AND not paying any attention to the timer! She'd always say,"They're a little burnt on the bottom!" ;-) I think that is definitely why I am very meticulous when I cook/bake. Have you tried Marta's 3-ingredient peanut butter cookies? She posted them awhile back...just made them and delivered some to our local firemen the other day! Thanks for sharing!

  10. Ah, I love reading your posts. I swear we're long-lost sisters!

  11. I am with you, the softer the cookie, the better. I like to make cookies out of cake mixes, because they always turn out soft. I made these cookies last weekend that take chocolate pudding, and they are still soft a week later (and still delicious!): http://www.yourhomebasedmom.com/smores-cookies/

  12. ahhhh! i am SUCH a cookie snob! haha! can't wait to try pudding-sounds like a smart move!

    (love your blog!!)

  13. This is very similar to my go to cookie recipe. It is actually my mother-in-law's and before hubby and I were married, I tried lots of other recipes out on him but none could ever measure up to his mom's. Boy am I glad to have this recipe!! It is so yummy!

  14. pudding?! really?! okay now i've got to get off this couch and go grab me something sweet to eat thanks to your post ;)

  15. TOTAL cookie snob. almost embarrassed by it. crispy cookies need to DIE. seriously. and pudding?? really?? can't wait to try!

  16. I'm not a COOKIE snob.
    I'm just a snob

    not really

    but a cake snob?

    will have to make these...
    now tell me...miss chewy cookie snob...have you made my angel kiss cookies? because you will LOOOVE them. I promise.

  17. Hey Mel - totally just put all of this on the grocery list for this weekend & planning on making them - they sound delicious!

    Random ?, but how do you take your Wednesday photos in the mirror? I've been trying to figure this out, but I keep ending up really blurry or with a giant flash in the picture...

  18. Do you beat in the pudding mix as powder form, or in pudding form?

  19. Wow! Never heard about the bread- I will need to try it- thanks. You always have the best ideas!

  20. To answer your question: Don't make the pudding...just add the dry pudding mix! :)

  21. These cookies turn out FANTASTIC!!! Thanks for the Vanilla pudding suggestion. They are the perfect soft cookie!

  22. sounds like a perfect cookie to me!!! i use the bread trick too!!!i am so going to try this recipe!!!

  23. I thought I was the only one. I too refuse to buy a processed cookie. Even Girl Scouts are a stretch for me. I only eat homemade and same as you, they have to be thick and chewy. I consider it a personal failure if a batch turns out flat. Even though my husband assures me they taste great. I still think they look horrible. I've tried that recipe with the jello and it's one of the only ones I'll use. Great tip on the bread! Thanks!

  24. Delicious. I am always up for new cookie recipes! The girls are so cute in the kitchen!

    Hey- did your giftcard come in yet? Hope you had a great weekend!

  25. They look great!! One trick I have found that works fantastic for the perfect consistency cookie is to use half butter and half margerine. Butter tends to make harder cookie, so even though I usually only ever bake with butter, margerine seems to make chocolate chip cookies: perfect crispy edges, soft and chewy middle.

  26. i am cookie snob with you too. i like thick and chewy and no nuts. i hate crispy cookies! blech!!! i'm totally trying this recipe. wish i had the ingredients right now!

  27. Followed your link from Kelly's Korner...I have never thought of adding pudding to chocolate chip cookies (though I add it to cakes all the time), but that is pure genius! I'm going to try these this weekend...thanks for sharing! :)

  28. I made cookies with your recipe and LOVED them. Even my hubby who doesn't like cookies ate several. Looks like my Grammy's recipe is out the door, now. Thanks for posting this!!

  29. Yum! I cannot wait to make these this weekend!

    I'm also a soft and chewy cookie girl! Never understand why one wants theirs hard as a brick, but to each their own! :)

  30. These look fab! I will have to try them. :)

  31. i am a total cookie snob.

    i never ever use semi sweet. milk chocolate all the way!

  32. bread with the cookies?!?! you smarty pants!

  33. Vanilla pudding mix is awesome in banana bread also..thx for sharing your recipe.

  34. Best cookies ever Mel! I think I ate almost 20 of them which is not so good for my get back to pre-baby weight plan but oh well. lol

  35. YUM...do you think this would work for peanut butter? I'm going to try it!

  36. Used this recipe! Delicious! Very soft. Not recommended for those who like their cookies crisp and chewy. But that doesn't mean they're not delicious! Thank you for sharing!

  37. Used this recipe! Delicious! Very soft. Not recommended for those who like their cookies crisp and chewy. But that doesn't mean they're not delicious! Thank you for sharing!

  38. de-to-the-lish! i made these sunday afternoon for our small group bible study ~ they were loved by all. such a great soft cookie recipe. thank you very much!

  39. My daughter and I made these this evening. She was not paying attention and added banana cream pudding rather than vanilla. They are awesome! Big hit with the family! She looked and me and said "can we make this mistake always mommy?" Too cute. Thanks for the recipe.

  40. Many people want to increase their muscle mass and create a toned, developed body that is
    not only aesthetically pleasing, but strong and healthy as
    well. Yes we would like muscle, but in the right way, and gaining lean muscle without fat is the key
    to doing this. In general, there is no doubt that the program
    Kyle Leon is a popular muscle building system for a good reason and this is definitely one of the most individual nutrients
    and online training programs today.

    my blog post ... Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Review

  41. Hello! I just wanted you to know I found this cookie recipe years ago (probably in 2011, shortly after you posted it), and I have been making these cookies ever since. My family LOVES them, and they are always a hit when I bring them to a party or gathering. The pudding makes them perfectly soft, and the bread trick for storing the cookies is a brilliant tip that I've passed on to many friends. Over the years, I've just Googled "cookie snobs unite" to get the recipe (which I have memorized... but just want to have on hand in case I screw up!). But today, I finally cut-and-paste this recipe into a Word doc to print out and put with my other recipes. Anyway — thank you! (And Merry Christmas!)



Blog Widget by LinkWithin